15 Caribbean Islands Ranked: 8 Worth Revisiting and 7 to Skip (Despite Great Experiences)
The Caribbean, with its vibrant culture and breathtaking landscapes, continues to captivate travelers seeking a mix of relaxation and adventure. In 2024, the region experienced an impressive 18% increase in visitor arrivals, driven by strategic marketing and enhanced connectivity, highlighting its enduring appeal as a premier travel destination.
Despite this growth, islands like St. Lucia and Turks and Caicos remain must-visit destinations for their unique attractions. Conversely, other islands, despite offering great experiences, may be skipped by travelers due to factors like overcrowding or commercialization. Here are 15 Caribbean islands ranked: 8 worth revisiting and 7 to skip, despite great experiences.
8 Caribbean Islands Worth Revisiting:
Aruba
Aruba, a small island in the southern Caribbean, is a gem worth revisiting for its unique blend of desert landscapes and pristine beaches. The island’s consistently warm weather and safety make it an attractive destination for travelers seeking a relaxing getaway. Aruba’s ease of travel, with many amenities similar to those in the US, adds to its appeal.
Visitors can enjoy activities like snorkeling and exploring the island’s natural wonders, such as the Arikok National Park. Aruba is a must-visit for any Caribbean traveler, offering a mix of natural beauty and modern conveniences.
Barbados
Barbados is a standout island worth revisiting, offering a blend of vibrant culture, stunning beaches, and a low crime rate. The island’s historic sites, such as Bridgetown, a UNESCO World Heritage Site, provide a glimpse into its rich colonial past. Visitors can enjoy activities like catamaran cruises and exploring local markets to taste Bajan cuisine.
Barbados’ friendly locals and rare hurricanes make it a safe and enjoyable destination. Barbados is a must-visit for any traveler to the Caribbean, offering a unique cultural heritage and natural beauty.
St. Lucia
St. Lucia is a breathtaking island worth revisiting, known for its dramatic landscapes and exciting outdoor activities. The iconic Pitons, volcanic plugs rising from the lush green landscape, are a must-see. Visitors can enjoy zip-lining through the rainforest or exploring the scenic Moule, a Chique peninsula.
According to Statista, this Caribbean destination welcomed over one million tourists in 2023, a significant rise from the nearly 737 thousand recorded in 2022. St. Lucia’s vibrant culture and stunning natural beauty make it a perfect destination for nature lovers and adventure seekers. St. Lucia is a must-visit for any Caribbean traveler, offering a unique blend of adventure and relaxation.
Turks & Caicos
Turks & Caicos is a hidden gem worth revisiting, offering pristine beaches and crystal-clear waters. The islands are famous for their stunning natural beauty, with activities like snorkeling at Coral Gardens and exploring secluded beaches on North and Middle Caicos. The local cuisine is renowned for its fresh seafood, and the friendly people add to the island’s charm.
According to Statista, the Turks and Caicos Islands recorded around 430 thousand inbound tourist arrivals in 2021. Turks & Caicos provides a tranquil and secluded experience, making it ideal for those seeking relaxation. Turks & Caicos is a must-visit destination, boasting stunning beaches and a laid-back atmosphere.
Cayman Islands
The Cayman Islands are a popular destination worth revisiting, known for their beautiful beaches and vibrant culture. Grand Cayman offers attractions like Stingray City, where visitors can swim with gentle stingrays, and the Cayman Turtle Centre. The islands also have stunning natural sites like the Crystal Caves and Queen Elizabeth II Botanic Park.
Statista said approximately 660 thousand international tourists visited the Cayman Islands in 2020, including around 540 thousand same-day visitors. With its mix of adventure and relaxation, the Cayman Islands are a must-visit for any Caribbean traveler. The islands’ upscale amenities and beautiful landscapes make them a favorite among tourists.
Bahamas (Exuma Cays)
The Exuma Cays in the Bahamas are a must-visit destination, famous for their crystal-clear waters and stunning beaches. Visitors can enjoy activities like snorkeling with sea turtles and exploring the Thunderball Grotto. The area is known for its unique wildlife, including swimming with nurse sharks at Compass Cay.
According to The Islands of The Bahamas, foreign air arrivals rose by 17% in 2023, reaching 1,719,980 visitors compared to 1,470,244 in 2022. The Exuma Cays offer a tranquil and natural experience for those seeking an off-the-beaten-path adventure. They are a must-revisit for any Caribbean traveler, offering pristine beauty and exciting activities.
Puerto Rico
Puerto Rico is a vibrant island worth revisiting. It offers a mix of stunning beaches, lush rainforests, and rich cultural heritage. The island is home to El Yunque National Forest, the only tropical rainforest on US soil, and three bioluminescent bays. Visitors can enjoy activities like hiking and exploring historic sites in San Juan.
According to Macrotrends, Puerto Rico saw 2.92 billion in tourism revenue in 2020, a 19.13% decline from 2019. Puerto Rico’s unique blend of Spanish and American influences makes it a fascinating destination for cultural enthusiasts. Puerto Rico is a must-visit for any traveler to the Caribbean, offering diverse landscapes and a vibrant culture.
Grenada
Grenada, known as the Spice Island, is a hidden gem worth revisiting for its lush rainforests, stunning waterfalls, and vibrant culture. The island offers various outdoor activities like hiking and snorkeling, as well as cultural experiences like visiting historic forts and rum distilleries. Grenada’s laid-back atmosphere and beautiful landscapes make it a perfect destination for nature lovers and those seeking relaxation.
According to Statista, around 504,000 same-day and overnight tourists visited Grenada, a Caribbean nation in the West Indies, in 2023. The island’s unique cultural heritage, blending African and European influences, adds charm. Grenada is a must-visit for any Caribbean traveler, offering natural beauty and a rich culture.
7 Caribbean Islands to Skip (Despite a Great Experience) :
Jamaica
Jamaica offers a unique cultural experience, but some travelers might consider skipping it despite its great experiences. The island is famous for its vibrant music scene and stunning natural beauty, including Dunn’s River Falls. However, safety concerns in certain areas and a reliance on tourism can detract from the overall experience.
Jamaica’s economy has faced challenges, particularly after the COVID-19 pandemic, which has impacted the local atmosphere. Despite these challenges, Jamaica remains a popular destination for those seeking a lively Caribbean experience.
Dominican Republic
The Dominican Republic, known for its beautiful beaches and resorts, is an island that some travelers might skip despite its great experiences. It can feel overly touristy despite offering a comprehensive travel experience with historical sites and cultural attractions. The island’s vibrant culture and stunning landscapes, such as those in the Taino settlements, are undeniable attractions.
However, concerns about safety and the impact of mass tourism can make it less appealing to some visitors. The Dominican Republic remains a popular destination, offering a mix of natural beauty and cultural richness, but it may not be ideal for those seeking a more authentic experience.
St. Thomas (US Virgin Islands)
St. Thomas, part of the US Virgin Islands, is an island that some travelers might skip despite its great experiences. The island offers stunning beaches and a vibrant nightlife, making it a popular destination for those seeking a lively Caribbean getaway. However, the high cost of living and limited cultural experiences compared to other islands can detract from the overall experience.
St. Thomas is ideal for those seeking a U.S.-style vacation with easy access to amenities. Despite its attractions, some travelers may find it less authentic than other Caribbean destinations.
Nassau (Bahamas)
Nassau, the capital of the Bahamas, is a city that some travelers might consider skipping despite its great experiences. The area can feel overly commercialized, despite offering a mix of colonial history and vibrant culture. Visitors can enjoy activities like snorkeling and exploring the local markets, but safety concerns and crowds can detract from the experience.
Nassau’s airport is well-equipped, making it a convenient stop for travelers. However, other destinations might be more appealing for those seeking a more secluded or authentic Caribbean experience.
Antigua
Antigua, known for its colonial architecture and vibrant culture, is an island that some travelers might consider skipping despite its great experiences. The island offers stunning beaches and a rich history, but can feel overly focused on large wedding groups and tourism. Antigua’s unique cultural heritage and scenic landscapes are undeniable attractions, but the island’s development and service quality can vary.
Other Caribbean islands might be more suitable for those seeking a more relaxed or off-the-beaten-path experience. Despite this, Antigua remains a popular destination for its charm and historical sites.
St. Maarten
St. Maarten, a half-Dutch, half-French island, is a destination that some travelers might skip despite its great experiences. The island offers a vibrant nightlife on the Dutch side and a more laid-back atmosphere on the French side. However, the island’s small size and divided personality can make it feel less authentic or diverse than other Caribbean destinations.
St. Maarten is famous for its heart-racing plane landings at Maho Beach, but it can also feel crowded and touristy. Other islands might be more appealing for those seeking a more secluded experience.
US Virgin Islands
While offering stunning beaches and snorkeling opportunities, the US Virgin Islands are a destination that some travelers might consider skipping despite their great experiences. The islands, particularly St. John, are renowned for their pristine beaches and national parks. However, the high cost of living and limited cultural experiences compared to other Caribbean islands can detract from the overall experience.
The USVI offers a U.S.-style vacation with easy amenities, but those seeking a more authentic Caribbean experience may prefer other destinations. Despite this, the USVI remains popular for nature lovers and beach enthusiasts.
Disclaimer – This list is solely the author’s opinion based on research and publicly available information. It is not intended to be professional advice.
Read More:
- 10 Extreme Measures People Took To Travel on the Cheap
- Do You Need A Passport To Go on A Cruise
- 15 Best Countrıes to Vısıt in Afrıca
